The client who's being unreasonably demanding might have just had terrible news. The colleague who snapped at you in the meeting might be going through something at home they haven't told anyone about. The partner who's been distant lately might be carrying more than you know.
It took me years to really understand this: most difficult behaviour has very little to do with you. People are fighting battles you can't see, and doing their best with whatever they have left that day.
Once I started assuming positive intent instead of bad intent, a lot changed. My stress levels, my relationships, and honestly, my business results too.
The story we tell ourselves
When someone treats you badly, your brain immediately writes a story about why. They're selfish. They don't respect your time. They're trying to take advantage of you.
Those stories feel true, because they're built on the little information you have. But they're usually wrong.
When I was younger, my first instinct when a supplier missed a deadline or a partner made a call I didn't like was some version of: they don't care enough. That was almost never true. People nearly always do what makes sense given what they know and what they're dealing with.
Why do we assume the worst?
Psychologists have a name for it: the fundamental attribution error. The term was coined by Lee Ross in 1977, and it describes our tendency to over-emphasise someone's personality and under-emphasise their situation when we explain their behaviour.
In plain words: we judge others by their actions and ourselves by our intentions. When you're late, it's the traffic. When someone else is late, they don't respect your time. When you're distracted, it's a family issue. When they're distracted, they don't care.
That double standard damages relationships before they've had a chance to grow.
What I do instead
When someone's behaviour frustrates me, I try to pause and ask one question: what else could be going on here that would explain this?
Maybe the person who didn't answer my email is dealing with a crisis at home. Maybe the client who keeps changing the brief is getting pressure from above that they can't tell me about. Maybe the colleague who seems checked out is simply overwhelmed.
That doesn't mean accepting bad behaviour or letting people walk over me. It means responding from curiosity instead of defensiveness, and understanding the situation before I react to it.
How to actually do it
- Pause before you react. Take a breath and remind yourself you don't know the whole story.
- Ask instead of assuming. "Is everything okay?" or "What would help most right now?" often reveals something that changes the whole picture.
- Give people more than one chance. Everyone has bad days, weeks, even months. Don't write someone off after one difficult moment.
- Focus on what you control. You can't control how others behave. You can control how you respond.
It's also good business
Assuming positive intent isn't just about being a nice person. When you understand the real reason behind someone's behaviour, you can solve the actual problem instead of fighting symptoms.
People can feel whether you're giving them the benefit of the doubt or expecting the worst, and they respond much better to the first. Being angry at other people all the time is exhausting. And word gets around about how you treat people, especially when they're going through a hard time. Being the one who responds with understanding builds a reputation that opens doors.
Boundaries still matter
This isn't about becoming a doormat. Understanding why someone is struggling is different from letting them take it out on you again and again.
Set clear boundaries, but say them with empathy rather than anger. Something like: "I understand you're dealing with a lot right now, but we need to find a way of working that works for both of us."
Every difficult interaction is a choice. You can assume bad intent and respond defensively, which feels good for a moment and usually makes things worse. Or you can assume positive intent and respond with curiosity, which feels a bit more vulnerable and usually makes things better.
Quick answers
What does "assume positive intent" mean?
It means that when someone behaves badly, you first assume there's a reason you can't see, instead of assuming they're doing it to hurt you.
What is the fundamental attribution error?
A term coined by Lee Ross in 1977 for our tendency to blame other people's behaviour on their personality and overlook their situation.
Does assuming positive intent mean accepting bad behaviour?
No. You can understand why someone is struggling and still set clear boundaries about what you accept.
Sources: Simply Psychology, "Fundamental Attribution Error", https://www.simplypsychology.org/fundamental-attribution.html