In the same week, I met two people who could have been the same person on paper.
Both had about twenty solid years behind them. Same industry, similar background, at the stage of their career where opportunities should be coming to them. One of them was being approached all the time. The other one was quietly wondering where all the calls had gone.
It had nothing to do with talent, credentials or even the size of their network. One of them clearly existed online. The other one didn't.
What "existing online" actually means
I don't mean a big following or viral posts. I mean something much simpler.
When you searched the first person's name, you found a LinkedIn profile with real substance, a clear point of view, some published thinking, and the same story everywhere you looked. By the time any conversation started, the trust was already half built. Their expertise arrived before they did.
When you searched the second person, you found either nothing, or a few outdated bits and pieces that said nothing about who they are today.
So one of them was in the running before the first meeting. The other one was starting from zero every single time.
The meeting you don't know is happening
Before almost any serious opportunity today, someone does a quick check. Nothing formal. They type your name into Google, open your LinkedIn, or ask an AI assistant who the credible people in your field are.
This isn't a hunch. A CareerBuilder survey found that 70% of employers use social media to screen candidates, and 57% are less likely to invite someone to an interview if they can't find them online at all. That was hiring, and it was a few years ago, before people started asking ChatGPT. In my experience clients, partners and investors do exactly the same thing now.
In 15 years of building businesses across Europe and Asia, I've seen it become as normal as glancing at a business card. Except this business card printed itself, it updates itself, and most people have never actually read what it says.
Talent and visibility are two different things
What I find most frustrating is that the most experienced people are often the least visible. They spent their careers doing the work: building companies, leading teams, closing deals. Meanwhile their online presence sat there untouched, outdated or completely empty.
And people with half their experience but a much clearer presence get the introductions and the invitations.
That's a visibility gap. The good news is that it's fixable. The annoying news is that most people only notice it when they need it.
What actually needs to change
You don't need to become a content machine or an influencer. It actually comes down to three things, done consistently rather than intensely:
- A clear, current presence. Something that shows who you are today, not five years ago, and tells anyone who lands on your profile what you're about in under ten seconds.
- A body of work, even a small one. Articles, posts, written thinking. Depth shows expertise in a way a profile summary never can. AI assistants look for exactly that kind of documented knowledge when they decide who to recommend.
- Consistency over time. Not daily posting. Just showing up with something real, regularly enough that a pattern forms. Someone who publishes something genuine once a week for a year has built something that compounds. Someone who bursts for three weeks and disappears has built very little.
The cost of waiting
This is the part people underestimate. It compounds in both directions.
Every week someone in your field publishes something real, their name gets a little more connected to their expertise. Their thinking gets indexed, found and referenced. AI systems learn to mention them. The gap grows even if you stand still, simply because they keep moving.
And it all happens silently. You don't get a notification when you're filtered out of a conversation. The opportunity just never shows up, and there's no obvious reason why.
The people I've seen close this gap didn't reinvent themselves. They made one simple decision: to stop treating their online presence as something for later, and start treating it as part of the job. One platform, kept up to date. A real point of view, shared every now and then. A body of work, built over time.
You don't have to be the loudest person in the room. You just have to be findable.
Quick answers
Why does professional visibility online matter?
Before almost any serious opportunity, someone searches your name. What they find decides whether you're in the running before the first meeting.
Do employers really check people online?
A CareerBuilder survey found 70% of employers use social media to screen candidates, and 57% are less likely to interview someone they can't find online.
How do you become more visible online?
A clear, current presence, a small body of written work, and showing up consistently over time.
Sources: CareerBuilder social media recruitment survey (2017), https://www.careerbuilder.com/advice/blog/social-media-survey-2017