I've sat in enough rooms over 15 years to say this with confidence: the best person in the room doesn't always get the deal. Not even close.
The one who gets it is usually the one whose credibility was there before they walked in. Whose name already sounded familiar. Whose thinking the client had already read somewhere. They didn't arrive as a stranger asking to be trusted. They arrived as someone the other side already felt they knew.
Visibility vs talent: what actually decides it
Relationships have always come before business. That part isn't new. What changed is where those relationships now start: online, before anyone books a meeting.
The pattern I keep seeing goes like this. Two people are up for the same opportunity. Similar background, similar experience, both perfectly able to deliver. One has a body of published thinking under their name: articles, posts, a consistent voice on the topics that matter in their field. The other has a LinkedIn profile and a strong reputation inside their own company.
The client does their homework before the meeting. They read one piece from the first person and feel like they know how that person thinks. So they walk in with a preference they haven't even admitted to themselves.
The more experienced person is now pitching to someone who's already leaning the other way. The outcome was shaped before the meeting started.
Does published thinking really change decisions?
It does, and there's data on it. In the 2024 Edelman and LinkedIn study of nearly 3,500 decision-makers, more than three-quarters admitted that a specific piece of thought leadership had pushed them to look into a product or service they hadn't considered before.
One article can put you on a shortlist you didn't know existed.
Why this feels unfair
When people first notice this, they get frustrated, and I understand why. It feels like the wrong thing is deciding. The quality of the work should matter.
And it does, eventually. Once you're in the room, substance beats performance every time. Real expertise can't be faked for long, and shallow expertise always shows itself. The people I've seen build a big online presence on thin knowledge don't last. It catches up with them in the first serious project.
But getting into the room, and onto the shortlist before the room is even booked, needs something else. Your expertise has to travel beyond the network you're already in, to the people who don't know you yet. Visibility carries your substance to places your work can't reach on its own.
Build both, in the right order
So you build both, in the right order:
- Substance first. Be genuinely good. Deliver real results. None of that changes.
- Then make it findable. For the people who are already looking: a peer searching your field, a recruiter checking a referral, a client doing homework, an AI assistant deciding who to recommend.
- Keep it honest. What people find should reflect what you can actually do. Nothing more.
The people who win most don't have the most visibility. They have both: real substance, and a presence that reflects it honestly. That combination is very hard to compete with.
A quick test
Search your name in a private browser window. Then ask yourself: does what comes up give a client, recruiter or partner confidence, or does it raise quiet questions?
If the honest answer is "questions" or "nothing at all", you already know what needs to change. Your expertise is fine. People just can't see it yet. And that part is entirely fixable.
Quick answers
Why do less experienced people sometimes win the deal?
Because their credibility was built before the meeting. The client had already read their thinking and walked in leaning their way.
Does thought leadership influence buying decisions?
In the 2024 Edelman and LinkedIn study, more than three-quarters of decision-makers said a specific piece of thought leadership pushed them to look into something they hadn't considered before.
Should I focus on substance or visibility?
Both, in that order. Substance first, then make it findable for the people already looking.
Sources: Edelman and LinkedIn, 2024 B2B Thought Leadership Impact Report, https://www.edelman.com/ca/insights/using-thought-leadership-engage-untapped-potential